Harrison Ford Is So Good as a Bad Guy, He Only Needed To Play One Once

The Big Picture

• Harrison Ford delivers a chilling and surprising performance in What Lies Beneath , showing a different side of his talents.
• The film is a departure for both Ford and director Robert Zemeckis, as it delves into the horror and psychological thriller genres.
• Ford's character starts as a seemingly noble protector but gradually reveals a manipulative and villainous side, adding depth to the story.

In the fading summer of 1999, Robert Zemeckis took a break from the filming of Cast Away to make What Lies Beneath, a ghostly thriller set against the banks of Lake Champlain in picturesque Burlington, Vermont. Taking cues from several Old Hollywood classics of the genre but adding a spectral twist to the proceedings, Zemeckis went on to craft one of the most underrated and effective offerings from that era (released at a time when there was a lot of competition in flicks like Stir of Echoes and The Sixth Sense). Michelle Pfeiffer and Harrison Ford were his first choices for the lead roles — Claire and Dr. Norman Spencer, an apparently happy couple with demons to spare — and swiftly made themselves available. Ford reportedly made sure to clear space in his schedule to accommodate What Lies Beneath, and for unsuspecting viewers predisposed to seeing a certain heroic brand of Ford, it ended up proving to be one of the most surprising and exciting turns of his illustrious film career.

It goes without saying that Harrison Ford has crafted many an iconic character throughout his many decades contributing to the silver screen. In What Lies Beneath, it is more than fair to assert that Ford is cast against type, but the audience isn't necessarily aware just how against type this duplicitous husband is until fairly late in the movie. Multilayered and guarded to a sinister extent, Ford nails the role, and it's thrilling to witness his character's chilling true intentions rise to the surface. While his trademark stoicism remains, the darker, more twisted psychology of the role allows Ford to exhibit a truly different side — especially as the thriller hurtles through its frenetic third act to the tune of a jittery, anxiety-inducing Alan Silvestri score.

What Lies Beneath

Robert Zemeckis' 'What Lies Beneath' Is a Haunting Thriller

What Lies Beneath remains the closest that Harrison Ford has come to making a horror film. Here, Ford plays Norman Spencer, a pragmatic, middle-aged doctor who is a dedicated scientist and lecturer. In fact, it seems the audience is simply being introduced to another well-meaning family man. Married to Pfeiffer's Claire and stepfather to Claire's daughter, Caitlin (Katharine Towne), Norman is further presented as a decent and caring (if not always present) figure whose workaholic tendencies place increased strain on his relationship with his wife. Once Caitlin sets off for college and leaves their quiet, stately lakeside manse for the vibrancy of dorm life, Claire begins to suspect that unseen forces may be trying to communicate with her.

The Forgotten Western War B-Movie That Launched Harrison Ford’s Career

It’s no Star Wars, but this Western gave the Hollywood icon his first credited project.

Feeling profoundly empty with Caitlin gone and Norman away at the lab for extended periods, Claire's prolonged periods of isolation at home feed into her burgeoning fear. She also spends a lot of time spying on her bickering neighbors and begins to suspect that the woman next door was murdered. Bathtubs fill inexplicably, the same framed picture falls multiple times, stereos blare to life without warning, and watery visages appear in the lake. Could the woman she's seeing and hearing be the neighbor's slain wife? Or is her over-protective and increasingly skeptical husband involved? The questions mount as Zemeckis piles on red herrings and misdirects. The director cleverly uses space and long sweeping shots to execute his nifty paranormal vehicle, and What Lies Beneath ends up serving as an unexpected departure for both the director and Ford.

Harrison Ford Plays Michelle Pfeiffer's Manipulative Husband in 'What Lies Beneath'

As Claire's obsession with whatever has invaded their home spirals, so too does her desperation. Norman becomes evasive and eventually incredulous, impatient with her insistence as she undertakes her own investigation. Led down the path of a missing college student from a year before, Claire fixates on Madison (Amber Valletta), a young woman whose appearance matches the spirit bedeviling their home. Worn down by fear, self-doubt, and a growing sense that she may be losing her grip, Claire falls down a rabbit hole and subsequently begins to shine a light on the series of events behind the perceived ghost's infiltration. Up until What Lies Beneath's midpoint, Norman is portrayed by Ford as an increasingly agitated observer. Mildly concerned at first, he eventually begins to suspect his wife is concocting the story to derail his research and reputation. It's here that the first signs of the character's narcissism arrive, and Ford deftly shifts from surface-level care to deep-seated cunning. He sends his wife to a psychiatrist in the hopes that the "ghost" can be eliminated through therapy and tries to dodge any suggestion he may be withholding information until Claire is given a supernatural glimpse at a past encounter between the two — a memory buried due to a traumatic incident the year before.

Harrison Ford Is the Total Package in This '90s Blockbuster

This one-off movie crystallized Ford's leading man image better than Indiana Jones or Star Wars.

The shedding of layers occurs gradually. Ford's Norman dismisses Claire's fantasies as delusion, consistently trivializing the matter until his past actions are remembered by Claire. Doing away with the incredulity and reappearing sincere again becomes the new play for Norman — but only because it becomes apparent that his livelihood is in jeopardy. The way Ford's portrayal gradually goes from apparently noble protector to self-serving manipulator is a delicate switch. Unlike The Fugitive, What Lies Beneath's protagonist looks to be running from something he is, in fact, completely responsible for!

Casting Harrison Ford as a Villain Works as a Brilliant Misdirect

The inherent ingenuity of What Lies Beneath is in its casting. Despite it becoming increasingly clear that Norman is deceitful, it's hard to immediately accept him as the primary perpetrator. Even as the proud facade continues to slide, the surprises remain undulled. Ford's typically heroic appeal is disarming in What Lies Beneath, even if early on one might detect the vague sense that his character is haunted by vaulted secrets itching for escape. The sentences that trail off, the gazes into space when talking to Claire ... the signs are all there.

In 2022, Bill Skarsgård's presence in Barbarian misdirected audiences accustomed to his leering portrayal of Pennywise the Clown in It. Similarly, on the against-type-casting front, Denzel Washington shifted gears considerably when he played corrupt cop Alonzo Harris in Training Day, and Henry Fonda famously played a very uncharacteristic dark part in Sergio Leone's Once Upon a Time in the West, subbing in for the inimitable Gian Maria Volonté as the film's chief antagonist in the piece. In the case of Ford in What Lies Beneath, however, it's never immediately obvious just how cold and calculating his character might be, and it's the subtle sense of deception and slow-emerging villainy imbued by both star and director that render the experience so effective. With pressure building on Norman and his connection to the missing Madison becoming more clear, Claire seeks closure. Following confrontations and a futile attempt by Norman to "exorcise" the spirit, Claire exerts every ounce of energy to extract the absolute, unambiguous truth regarding the student's demise, but is consistently met with varying forms of denial.

Unconvinced, she persists to her own detriment. Norman, when in control, makes it clear he is capable of going to the farthest lengths to protect his life and status quo. Shot mid-length and cast in half-shadow, the full extent of the character's arrant heartlessness is revealed. Suffice to say, What Lies Beneath's final 30 minutes evolve into a jaw-dropping outlier in Ford's filmography. It's a thoroughly dark role inhabited by Ford, and the film's effectiveness is heightened by the actor's presence. The viewer is reluctant to fully accept Norman as a villain in the traditional sense until it's far too late. It's a credit to the actor's interpretation of a multi-layered character and a script that drip-feeds its arcs. The viewer is swept up in the plight of its heroine, as well as the narrative diversions and occasionally well-worn trappings of the genre, before having to fully reckon with Ford's villainous turn.

Harrison Ford's patented rugged charm is still here but only in part — a fallible outer layer veiling the self-absorbed and murderously determined true character within. Windows into Norman's treachery are provided early, but they are subtle peepholes into someone whose concerns are ultimately shallow. When all bets are off, Ford is playing a character who will go down any and every road necessary to sustain a faux-perfect life. You may not realize it at first, but once Zemeckis starts turning the screws, it becomes abundantly clear that What Lies Beneath is a serious detour for one of our biggest movie stars.

What Lies Beneath is available to rent on Prime Video in the U.S.

RENT ON PRIME VIDEO

ncG1vNJzZmibn6G5qrDEq2Wcp51kxKmt02ajop2jYq%2BmusSaq6FlmJa%2Fs7XSqKVmnp%2BnsXA%3D